AI 對話紀錄  March 20, 2025

【AG-05】Posting to Facebook/WhatsApp from AppGini Webapp

Q: Another wild idea here! Do you think it's possible to write a post on the AppGini generated app (Say in the social_post table) and output it to Facebook/Instagram/WhatsApp (All under Meta) with some form of API call or intermediate platform? Of course I'm assuming a low-code approach. I observe that the pastor has to write WhatsApp and social post quite often. It will be good if those historical content can be stored inside the operation-CMS combo for future reference nd reuse. With these content, I can even record their performance with a post_performance table!

---

A: Yes, it’s definitely possible to write a post in your AppGini-generated app (e.g., in the social_post table) and output it to Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp using a low-code approach. This can streamline the pastor’s workflow by centralizing content creation, and you can absolutely store historical posts in your operational-CMS combo for future reference and reuse. Plus, tracking performance with a post_performance table is a great idea! Here’s how you can make it happen.

---

Overview

AppGini generates PHP-based web apps with a MariaDB backend, so your social_post table is already a solid starting point. To post from this table to Meta platforms (Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp), we’ll use a combination of an intermediate platform and some simple integrations. Since you prefer low-code, we’ll minimize custom coding and leverage existing tools. The trickiest part is WhatsApp, which operates differently from the others, but we’ve got options for that too.

---

Step 1: Posting to Facebook and Instagram

Facebook and Instagram are social media platforms with robust APIs (via Meta’s Graph API), but dealing with them directly can be complex. Instead, you can use an intermediate service like Ayrshare or Hootsuite, which simplifies posting across multiple platforms.

How It Works

• Choose a Service: Sign up for Ayrshare (or a similar platform) and connect your Facebook and Instagram accounts. Ayrshare supports both and provides a single API to handle posting.

• AppGini Integration: In your AppGini app, use a hook—like social_post_after_insert—to trigger a PHP script when a new post is added to the social_post table. This script sends the post content to Ayrshare’s API, which then distributes it to the connected platforms.

Sample Code

Here’s a simple PHP snippet you can add to your hook:

php

$api_key = 'your-ayrshare-api-key'; // Get this from Ayrshare
$post_content = $data['post_content']; // Replace with your column name
$post_data = [
    'post' => $post_content,
    'platforms' => ['facebook', 'instagram'],
];
$ch = curl_init('https://app.ayrshare.com/api/post');
curl_setopt($ch, CURLOPT_POST, 1);
curl_setopt($ch, CURLOPT_POSTFIELDS, json_encode($post_data));
curl_setopt($ch, CURLOPT_HTTPHEADER, [
    'Content-Type: application/json',
    'Authorization: Bearer ' . $api_key,
]);
curl_setopt($ch, CURLOPT_RETURNTRANSFER, true);
$response = curl_exec($ch);
curl_close($ch);

• What This Does: When a post is saved in social_post, this code sends it to Ayrshare, which posts it to Facebook and Instagram.

• Why It’s Low-Code: You’re just making one API call—no need to wrestle with Meta’s APIs directly.

Notes

• Formatting: Ensure your social_post table has fields for content (e.g., text, image URLs) that match each platform’s needs. Instagram often requires images, while Facebook can handle text-only posts.

• Setup: You’ll need to link a Facebook Page for Instagram posting (required by Meta’s API).

• • *

Step 2: Handling WhatsApp

WhatsApp is different—it’s a messaging platform, not a social media feed. Its WhatsApp Business API is designed for customer communication, not broadcasting posts, which makes full automation trickier. However, we can still integrate it in a low-code way.

Option 1: Manual Posting with Pre-Filled Links

• How It Works: Generate a clickable WhatsApp link in your AppGini app that pre-fills the post content. The pastor can click it to open WhatsApp and send the message to a contact or group.

• Sample Code: Add this to your hook or detail view:

php

$phone_number = '1234567890'; // Target phone number or group admin
$message = urlencode($data['post_content']); // Replace with your column name
$whatsapp_link = "https://wa.me/{$phone_number}?text={$message}";
echo "<a href='{$whatsapp_link}' target='_blank'>Send via WhatsApp</a>";

• Pros: Super simple, no API setup needed—just a link!

• Cons: Requires manual clicking and sending, but it’s still faster than rewriting the post.

Option 2: WhatsApp Business API (Slightly More Complex)

• How It Works: Use the WhatsApp Business API to automate sending messages to specific contacts or groups.

• Requirements:

  • A WhatsApp Business account.

  • API access (apply through Meta or a provider like Twilio).

  • Pre-approved message templates (WhatsApp’s rule for automation).

• Integration: Add a PHP script in your hook to call the WhatsApp API, similar to the Ayrshare example.

• Pros: Fully automated.

• Cons: More setup (e.g., API approval) and possibly a third-party service like Twilio, which adds some cost and complexity.

Recommendation

Start with Option 1 for simplicity. If the pastor needs to send posts to a consistent group (e.g., a church announcement group), the link approach works well. You can explore Option 2 later if full automation becomes a priority.

---

Step 3: Storing Historical Content

Your social_post table can be the central hub for all posts, making it easy to reference and reuse content.

Setup

• Table Fields: Include columns like id, post_content, platforms (e.g., "facebook,instagram,whatsapp"), created_at, and status (e.g., "draft", "posted").

• Storage: Every post—whether sent to Facebook, Instagram, WhatsApp, or all three—gets saved here automatically when created in the AppGini app.

Benefits

• Searchable Archive: Filter posts by date, platform, or content for quick reuse.

• Pastor’s Workflow: No more rewriting—posts are stored and ready to adapt for future use.

• • *

Step 4: Tracking Performance

For platforms like Facebook and Instagram, you can record performance metrics (e.g., likes, shares) in a post_performance table.

How It Works

• Fetch Data: Use Ayrshare’s API (or the platform you choose) to retrieve analytics for posted content. Ayrshare, for example, offers endpoints to get engagement stats.

• Store It: Link each post in social_post to a record in post_performance with fields like post_id, platform, likes, shares, comments, and updated_at.

• Automation: Set up a cron job or scheduled task to periodically pull this data and update your table.

Sample Code (Analytics Fetch)

php

$ch = curl_init('https://app.ayrshare.com/api/analytics/post');
curl_setopt($ch, CURLOPT_HTTPHEADER, [
    'Authorization: Bearer ' . $api_key,
]);
curl_setopt($ch, CURLOPT_RETURNTRANSFER, true);
$analytics = json_decode(curl_exec($ch), true);
curl_close($ch);
// Insert $analytics into post_performance table

• Note: WhatsApp doesn’t provide performance metrics like social media, so this applies only to Facebook and Instagram.

• • *

Why This Rocks

• Low-Code: Ayrshare handles Facebook and Instagram with one API call, and WhatsApp links require minimal coding.

• Centralized: All posts live in social_post, saving time and effort for the pastor.

• Performance Insights: Track what works on Facebook and Instagram to refine future posts.

• Scalable: Start simple, then add WhatsApp automation if needed.

• • *

Next Steps

1. Sign Up: Get an Ayrshare account (they have a free tier) and connect your accounts.

2. Test the Hook: Add the Facebook/Instagram posting code to social_post_after_insert.

3. Add WhatsApp Links: Display the pre-filled link in your app’s interface.

4. Build Performance Tracking: Set up post_performance and test the analytics pull.

What do you think—ready to tattoo this idea onto your AppGini app? Let me know if you want help with the setup or more WhatsApp options!

---

Q: Superb! But for the WhatsApp link, will it appear as a pop-up or what? As we've had difficulty showing one with the __global.php hook. An alternative will be to generate the link code and insert it back into say a "whatsapp_code" field of the social_post table.

---

A: You’re right to flag the popup concern—since we’ve had trouble getting alerts to show with the __global.php hook in your setup, relying on a popup for the WhatsApp link might hit the same snag. Your alternative idea to generate the link and store it in a whatsapp_code field in the social_post table is a brilliant workaround! It sidesteps the display issue entirely, keeps everything tidy in your database, and gives the pastor a reusable link they can copy or click whenever needed. Let’s go with that and flesh it out—superb thinking!

---

Why Your Alternative Rocks

• Avoids Display Issues: No need to wrestle with popups or alerts that might not render due to buffering or redirects (like we saw with __global.php).

• Database-Driven: Storing the WhatsApp link in social_post keeps it alongside the post content, making it easy to access via the AppGini interface or reports.

• Flexibility: The pastor can copy the link manually, click it from the detail view, or even use it in bulk later (e.g., via a report or export).

• • *

How It Works

Step 1: Update the social_post Table

Add a field to store the WhatsApp link:

• Field: whatsapp_code (Text or Long Text, depending on post length).

• AppGini Setup: Open your project in AppGini, add whatsapp_code to the social_post table, regenerate, and upload to your QNAP server.

Step 2: Generate and Save the WhatsApp Link

Use the social_post_after_insert hook to create the link and save it back to the table when a post is added.

Here’s the code for hooks/social_post.php:

php

<?php
function social_post_after_insert($data, $memberInfo, &$args) {
    $post_id = $data['id']; // Assuming 'id' is your primary key
    $post_content = $data['post_content']; // Replace with your actual column name
    $phone_number = '1234567890'; // Default number (e.g., pastor’s phone or group admin)

    // Generate WhatsApp link
    $message = urlencode($post_content);
    $whatsapp_link = "https://wa.me/{$phone_number}?text={$message}";

    // Save link to whatsapp_code field
    sql("UPDATE social_post SET whatsapp_code = '$whatsapp_link' WHERE id = $post_id", $eo);

    // Optional: Post to Facebook/Instagram via Ayrshare (if implemented)
    /*
    $api_key = 'your-ayrshare-api-key';
    $post_data = [
        'post' => $post_content,
        'platforms' => ['facebook', 'instagram'],
    ];
    $ch = curl_init('https://app.ayrshare.com/api/post');
    curl_setopt($ch, CURLOPT_POST, 1);
    curl_setopt($ch, CURLOPT_POSTFIELDS, json_encode($post_data));
    curl_setopt($ch, CURLOPT_HTTPHEADER, [
        'Content-Type: application/json',
        'Authorization: Bearer ' . $api_key,
    ]);
    curl_setopt($ch, CURLOPT_RETURNTRANSFER, true);
    curl_exec($ch);
    curl_close($ch);
    */

    return TRUE;
}

• What It Does:

  • After a post is inserted, it grabs the id and post_content.

  • Creates a WhatsApp link with a hardcoded phone number (you can tweak this later).

  • Updates the whatsapp_code field with the link for that post.

• Phone Number: Replace '1234567890' with the pastor’s target number or a group admin’s number. You could also make this dynamic by adding a whatsapp_number field to social_post or pulling it from $memberInfo.

Step 3: Display the Link

Since popups didn’t work reliably, let’s show the link in the AppGini interface:

• Detail View: AppGini automatically displays whatsapp_code in the detail view of a social_post record as a clickable link (if it’s a Text field).

• Table View: Add it as a column so the pastor can see all links at a glance:

  • In AppGini, go to social_post table settings, ensure whatsapp_code is visible in the table view.

Alternatively, if you want a button-like experience without popups:

• Custom Link: Edit hooks/social_post-dv.js to style it:

  javascript

  $j(function() {
      var link = $j('#whatsapp_code').text();
      $j('#whatsapp_code_container').html(`<a href="${link}" target="_blank" class="btn btn-primary">Send via WhatsApp</a>`);
  });

• This turns the whatsapp_code field into a nice button in the detail view.

Step 4: Pastor’s Workflow

• Create Post: The pastor adds a post in the social_post table via AppGini.

• Get Link: After saving, they see the whatsapp_code in the detail view (e.g., “https://wa.me/1234567890?text=Check%20out%20our%20latest%20event!”).

• Use It: They copy the link, paste it into a browser, and send it via WhatsApp to their group or contacts.

• • *

Why This Solves the Popup Issue

• No Popups Needed: The link lives in the database and shows up naturally in AppGini—no reliance on echo or JavaScript alerts that might get buffered or blocked (like in __global.php).

• Persistent: Stored in whatsapp_code, it’s always there for later use, unlike a fleeting popup.

• • *

Tying It All Together

Here’s your full hooks/social_post.php with placeholders for Ayrshare and performance tracking:

php

<?php
function social_post_after_insert($data, $memberInfo, &$args) {
    $post_id = $data['id'];
    $post_content = $data['post_content'];
    $phone_number = '1234567890'; // Customize this

    // WhatsApp link
    $message = urlencode($post_content);
    $whatsapp_link = "https://wa.me/{$phone_number}?text={$message}";
    sql("UPDATE social_post SET whatsapp_code = '$whatsapp_link' WHERE id = $post_id", $eo);

    // Ayrshare for Facebook/Instagram (uncomment when ready)
    /*
    $api_key = 'your-ayrshare-api-key';
    $post_data = [
        'post' => $post_content,
        'platforms' => ['facebook', 'instagram'],
    ];
    $ch = curl_init('https://app.ayrshare.com/api/post');
    curl_setopt($ch, CURLOPT_POST, 1);
    curl_setopt($ch, CURLOPT_POSTFIELDS, json_encode($post_data));
    curl_setopt($ch, CURLOPT_HTTPHEADER, [
        'Content-Type: application/json',
        'Authorization: Bearer ' . $api_key,
    ]);
    curl_setopt($ch, CURLOPT_RETURNTRANSFER, true);
    curl_exec($ch);
    curl_close($ch);
    */

    return TRUE;
}

---

Next Steps

1. Add the Field: Put whatsapp_code in your social_post table and regenerate.

2. Test the Hook: Save a post and check if whatsapp_code fills with a clickable link.

3. Style It: Try the JS tweak if you want a button instead of plain text.

4. Ayrshare: Sign up when ready to add Facebook/Instagram posting.

This keeps it low-code and integrates beautifully with your operational-CMS combo. How’s Tattoo looking with that hero image hunt? Ready to test this WhatsApp trick? Let me know what you think!

---

Q: For Whatsapp, I think our link approach would only work with individual contacts but not a group right because a group doesn't have a phone number.

---

A: Absolutely, let’s walk through the Meta setup together so you can see if it’s manageable for you—it’s totally doable with a bit of patience! And you’re spot on about WhatsApp: the link approach (https://wa.me/) works great for individual contacts but not directly for groups, since WhatsApp groups don’t have phone numbers tied to them in the same way. I’ll address that limitation and suggest a tweak to make group posting workable, keeping it low-code and free. Here’s the plan:

---

Meta Setup for Facebook and Instagram

Step 1: Create a Meta Developer Account

• What to Do: Go to developers.facebook.com and sign up or log in with your existing Facebook account (e.g., the pastor’s or one tied to the chaplaincy).

• Effort: 2 minutes—pretty straightforward if you’ve got a Facebook login ready.

Step 2: Set Up a Facebook Page

• What to Do: If your chaplaincy doesn’t have a Page yet, create one at facebook.com/pages/create. Pick “Organization” or “Nonprofit,” add a name, and skip the fancy stuff for now.

• Why: The Graph API posts to Pages, not personal profiles.

• Effort: 5-10 minutes—quick unless you want to polish it up.

Step 3: Link Instagram

• What to Do:

  • Convert your Instagram account to a Business Account (Settings > Account > Switch to Professional Account > Business) if it’s not already.

  • Link it to your Facebook Page (on Facebook, go to Page Settings > Instagram > Connect Account).

• Why: Instagram posting via the Graph API requires a Business Account tied to a Page.

• Effort: 5 minutes—mostly clicking through menus.

Step 4: Create a Meta App

• What to Do:

  • On developers.facebook.com, click “My Apps” > “Create App.”

  • Choose “Business” as the app type (for Page and Instagram access).

  • Name it (e.g., “Chaplaincy Poster”) and hit “Create App.”

• Effort: 3-5 minutes—just a form to fill out.

Step 5: Add Permissions

• What to Do:

  • In your Meta app dashboard, go to “App Settings” > “Basic.”

  • Under “Products,” add “Facebook Login” and “Instagram Graph API.”

  • Request permissions: publish_to_pages, manage_pages (for Facebook), instagram_basic, instagram_content_publish (for Instagram).

• Note: For now, you can use it in “Development Mode” (no review needed for personal use). If it’s for public use later, Meta requires app review.

• Effort: 5-10 minutes—navigating the dashboard takes a moment.

Step 6: Get an Access Token

• What to Do:

  • Go to “Tools” > “Graph API Explorer” in the Meta Developer Portal.

  • Select your app, choose your Page under “Facebook Page,” and add the permissions from Step 5.

  • Click “Generate Access Token” (you’ll log in and approve).

  • Copy the token—it’s a long string (e.g., “EAAB…”).

• Tip: For a permanent token, extend it via “Access Token Debugger” (it lasts 60 days by default, but Page tokens can be made “never expire”).

• Effort: 5-10 minutes—fiddly but followable with a tutorial (Meta’s docs or YouTube can help).

Step 7: Test It

• What to Do: Plug the token and Page ID (from Graph API Explorer) into the hook I shared earlier. Save a post in social_post and see if it hits your Page!

• Effort: 5 minutes once you’ve got the token.

Your Call

• Manageable?: It’s a one-time setup—about 30-45 minutes total if you’re comfy clicking through menus and copying strings. No coding yet, just account prep.

• Help Needed?: If any step feels shaky (e.g., tokens), I can guide you with screenshots or a tighter walkthrough. What do you think so far?

• • *

WhatsApp: Handling Groups

You’re correct—the https://wa.me/ link only works for individual phone numbers, not groups, because groups in WhatsApp don’t have a direct phone number or URL. Here’s how we can adapt it for group posting while staying free and low-code:

Option 1: Use a Group Invite Link

• How It Works:

  • Create a WhatsApp group for announcements (e.g., “Chaplaincy Updates”).

  • Generate a group invite link (in WhatsApp: Group Info > Invite via Link > Copy Link).

  • Store this link in your app (e.g., hardcode it or add a whatsapp_group_link field to social_post).

  • Combine it with the post content for the pastor to share manually.

• Sample Code (Update the hook):

  php

  function social_post_after_insert($data, $memberInfo, &$args) {
      $post_id = $data['id'];
      $post_content = $data['post_content'];
  
      // WhatsApp group link
      $group_link = 'https://chat.whatsapp.com/your-group-invite-code'; // Replace with your group’s link
      $message = urlencode($post_content . "\nJoin us: $group_link");
      $whatsapp_link = "https://wa.me/1234567890?text=$message"; // Still uses a phone number to send
      sql("UPDATE social_post SET whatsapp_code = '$whatsapp_link' WHERE id = $post_id", $eo);
  
      return TRUE;
  }

• Workflow: The pastor clicks the whatsapp_code link, which opens WhatsApp with the post pre-filled, and sends it to a contact who can forward it to the group—or posts it directly if they’re an admin.

• Pros: Free, no API, works with your current setup.

• Cons: Still semi-manual—someone needs to forward it to the group.

Option 2: Admin Phone Number as Proxy

• How It Works:

  • Use the phone number of a group admin (e.g., the pastor’s) in the wa.me link.

  • The pastor sends the message to themselves, then forwards it to the group from their WhatsApp app.

• Code: Same as above, just set $phone_number to the pastor’s number.

• Pros: Keeps it simple and free.

• Cons: Extra step to forward.

Option 3: WhatsApp Business API (Not Free)

• Note: For full automation to groups, the WhatsApp Business API can send messages directly, but it requires:

  • A paid provider like Twilio (starts at $0.045/message) or Meta’s Cloud API (free tier limited, then $0.005-$0.015/message).

  • Template approval from Meta.

• Why Skip: Adds cost and complexity, breaking your free/low-code goal.

Best Bet

Stick with Option 1—generate a link with the post content and append the group invite link. The pastor can:

• Copy whatsapp_code, paste it into their browser, and send it to a contact or themselves.

• Forward it to the group manually from WhatsApp. It’s not fully automated, but it’s free, fits your setup, and keeps historical posts in social_post for reuse.

• • *

Next Move

• Meta Setup: Start with Step 1 (Meta Developer account) and Step 2 (Facebook Page). Tell me how it goes—e.g., “Got the Page, stuck on the app part.”

• WhatsApp Tweak: Add whatsapp_code with the group link approach to your hook. Test it with a dummy post and let me know if the link works for the pastor.

• Decide: If Meta feels too fiddly, we can lean harder on WhatsApp links and skip social for now—or use Ayrshare’s free tier for a bit.

What do you think—ready to dip into Meta’s developer portal? How’s that hero image wait going?

---

Q: I want to clarify two things. First, I think Facebook and WhatsApp posts are separated for now. I'm not sure whether to store them together or separately. For ease of hook programming maybe they should separate into two tables. Second, can the Meta API or immediate platforms directly post the textual content as drafts so that the pastor can edit and add video on the social platforms before publishing the post?

---

A: Great questions! Let’s clarify these two points and refine your setup to make it as smooth as possible for the pastor while keeping your low-code approach intact. I’ll address whether to separate Facebook and WhatsApp posts into different tables and whether the Meta API (or intermediate platforms) can post text as drafts for later editing and video addition.

---

1. Should Facebook and WhatsApp Posts Be Stored Together or Separately?

Current Setup

Right now, your social_post table likely handles all posts in one place with fields like:

• id

• post_content

• whatsapp_code

• status (Draft/Posted)

• video_note (optional)

This assumes posts might go to multiple platforms (Facebook, Instagram, WhatsApp), and the hook decides what to do based on content (e.g., text-only to Facebook, link for WhatsApp).

Pros of Keeping Them Together

• Simplicity: One table means one interface for the pastor to write posts—less clutter in AppGini.

• Reuse: A single post can be adapted for all platforms (e.g., tweak text for WhatsApp, add a video for Facebook).

• Unified History: All content lives in one spot for tracking and reference.

Cons of Keeping Them Together

• Hook Complexity: The social_post_after_insert hook has to juggle logic for each platform (e.g., Facebook API call, WhatsApp link generation), which can get messy if platforms diverge more (like video handling).

• Different Needs: WhatsApp posts are often shorter and chatty, while Facebook might need longer text or media—could feel awkward in one table.

Pros of Separating (e.g., facebook_post and whatsapp_post)

• Cleaner Hooks: Each table gets its own hook (facebook_post_after_insert, whatsapp_post_after_insert), making the code simpler and platform-specific.

• Tailored Fields:

  • facebook_post: id, post_content, video_url, status, fb_response

  • whatsapp_post: id, post_content, whatsapp_code, status

• Focus: The pastor can think “this is for WhatsApp” vs. “this is for Facebook” without mixing workflows.

Cons of Separating

• Duplication: If a post is meant for both platforms, the pastor enters it twice—more work.

• AppGini Overhead: Two tables mean two menu items, which might confuse non-tech users.

Recommendation

Since you’re unsure and want ease of hook programming, separating them into two tables makes sense for now:

• Why: It simplifies the hooks—each does one job (Facebook API or WhatsApp link)—and avoids conditional spaghetti code. You’re still early enough to split without much rework.

• How:

  • facebook_post: For Meta API posts (text, optional video).

  • whatsapp_post: For link-based WhatsApp messages.

• Future: If you see lots of overlap (e.g., same text across platforms), you could merge back later or add a “share to both” feature.

Updated Tables

• facebook_post:

  • id (PK)

  • post_content (Long Text)

  • video_url (Text, optional)

  • status (Options: Draft/Posted)

  • fb_response (Text, for API feedback)

• whatsapp_post:

  • id (PK)

  • post_content (Long Text)

  • whatsapp_code (Text)

  • status (Options: Draft/Posted)

• • *

2. Can Meta API or Intermediate Platforms Post Text as Drafts?

Meta Graph API (Direct)

• Facebook:

  • Drafts?: Yes, the Graph API supports posting as a draft! Use the unpublished_content endpoint or set published=false in the /feed call.

  • How It Works: The post goes to the Page as an unpublished draft. The pastor logs into Facebook, edits it (e.g., adds a video), and publishes it manually.

  • Sample Code:

    php

    function facebook_post_after_insert($data, $memberInfo, &$args) {
        $post_id = $data['id'];
        $post_content = $data['post_content'];
        $access_token = 'your-fb-access-token';
        $page_id = 'your-page-id';
    
        $url = "https://graph.facebook.com/v19.0/{$page_id}/feed";
        $params = [
            'message' => $post_content,
            'published' => false, // Saves as draft
            'access_token' => $access_token,
        ];
        $ch = curl_init($url);
        curl_setopt($ch, CURLOPT_POST, 1);
        curl_setopt($ch, CURLOPT_POSTFIELDS, http_build_query($params));
        curl_setopt($ch, CURLOPT_RETURNTRANSFER, true);
        $response = curl_exec($ch);
        curl_close($ch);
    
        sql("UPDATE facebook_post SET fb_response = '$response', status = 'Draft' WHERE id = $post_id", $eo);
        return TRUE;
    }

  • Result: The post appears under “Drafts” on the Page’s Publishing Tools tab in Facebook—perfect for adding videos later.

• Instagram:

  • Drafts?: No, the Graph API doesn’t support drafts for Instagram posts (images or Reels). It’s publish-or-nothing.

  • Workaround: Save as “Draft” in AppGini, let the pastor post manually with video via the Instagram app.

Intermediate Platforms (Ayrshare, Hootsuite)

• Ayrshare:

  • Drafts?: No direct draft feature in the free tier. Posts are either scheduled or published immediately. You’d need their Business plan ($499/month) for “Draft” status via their dashboard, but the API itself doesn’t expose this easily.

  • Workaround: Keep it as “Draft” in AppGini, post manually for now.

• Hootsuite:

  • Drafts?: Yes, Hootsuite’s paid plans ($99/month+) let you save drafts via their dashboard or API (/v1/messages with state=DRAFT), but it’s not free. The pastor could edit and add videos there before publishing.

  • Catch: Costs money, breaking your free preference.

WhatsApp

• Drafts?: The link approach doesn’t support drafts—it’s just a pre-filled message. The pastor sends it or saves it manually in WhatsApp as a draft (e.g., type it and leave it unsent).

• No Change Needed: Your whatsapp_code field already fits this workflow.

Recommendation

• Facebook: Use the Graph API with published=false to save as drafts—free and fits your need perfectly.

• Instagram: Keep as “Draft” in AppGini; no API draft option, so manual posting with video is best.

• WhatsApp: Stick with the link—drafts stay in AppGini until the pastor sends it.

• Why Skip Intermediates: Ayrshare/Hootsuite add cost for drafts, and Meta’s API does it free (for Facebook at least).

• • *

Updated Hooks

• hooks/facebook_post.php:

  php

  <?php
  function facebook_post_after_insert($data, $memberInfo, &$args) {
      $post_id = $data['id'];
      $post_content = $data['post_content'];
      $access_token = 'your-fb-access-token';
      $page_id = 'your-page-id';
  
      $url = "https://graph.facebook.com/v19.0/{$page_id}/feed";
      $params = [
          'message' => $post_content,
          'published' => false, // Draft mode
          'access_token' => $access_token,
      ];
      $ch = curl_init($url);
      curl_setopt($ch, CURLOPT_POST, 1);
      curl_setopt($ch, CURLOPT_POSTFIELDS, http_build_query($params));
      curl_setopt($ch, CURLOPT_RETURNTRANSFER, true);
      $response = curl_exec($ch);
      curl_close($ch);
  
      sql("UPDATE facebook_post SET fb_response = '$response', status = 'Draft' WHERE id = $post_id", $eo);
      return TRUE;
  }

• hooks/whatsapp_post.php:

  php

  <?php
  function whatsapp_post_after_insert($data, $memberInfo, &$args) {
      $post_id = $data['id'];
      $post_content = $data['post_content'];
      $phone_number = '1234567890'; // Pastor’s number
  
      $message = urlencode($post_content);
      $whatsapp_link = "https://wa.me/{$phone_number}?text={$message}";
      sql("UPDATE whatsapp_post SET whatsapp_code = '$whatsapp_link', status = 'Draft' WHERE id = $post_id", $eo);
  
      return TRUE;
  }

• • *

Your Call

• Separation: Splitting into facebook_post and whatsapp_post simplifies coding and fits your clarification—go for it unless the pastor insists on one table.

• Drafts: Meta API handles Facebook drafts beautifully; Instagram and WhatsApp stay manual but tracked as “Draft” in AppGini.

Next Steps

• Tables: Add facebook_post and whatsapp_post in AppGini, regenerate, and upload.

• Meta Setup: Start with that developer account and Page—let me know where you’re at (e.g., “Page done, token next”).

• Test: Try a text-only post in facebook_post—see if it lands as a draft on your Page.

What do you think—ready to split tables and dive into Meta? How’s that hero image wait going?

---

Sharing is sexy